Giuliani
risks it all for Trump. Why? They share a lifeboat.
He was a hero mayor and a star
prosecutor, but after some bad choices, he’s stuck with few options
By
Andrew Kirtzman, author of “Rudy Giuliani: Emperor of the City,” is
working on his second book about Giuliani.
Dec. 14, 2020 at 5:00 a.m. CST
Less than 24 hours
after entering Georgetown University Hospital last weekend with coronavirus symptoms,
Rudolph W. Giuliani was back on Twitter. “A MUST WATCH — VIDEO EVIDENCE FROM
GEORGIA!” he wrote, heralding yet
one more smoking gun to help revive his collapsing campaign to overturn the
presidential election results. It was a stark illustration of Giuliani’s
devotion to President Trump that he would tweet on the president’s behalf while
in a hospital bed. Even his illness was arguably Trump’s fault — he has
disparaged masks almost as much as the president has, and he spent much of the
previous week working without one.
The former mayor’s
humiliations in service of Trump have been piling up. He has become a
punchline, captured in a bedroom with a young woman in a movie; staging a news
conference at the wrong Four Seasons;
dripping hair dye and
introducing a stream of cartoon characters as witnesses in a
political conspiracy case that the courts aren’t buying. His credibility is
dissolving, one disaster at a time.
Why is Giuliani
willing to destroy his reputation for Trump? Why is he apparently willing
to die for Trump? For that matter, why is Trump still holding
on to Giuliani, who has been embarrassing him on a near daily basis since he
hired him?
On one level the
answer is self-evident: The two are trapped on a sinking lifeboat and
scrambling to save themselves in their waning days of power. How they ended up
there is less evident, but it can be found in the underpinnings of their
alliance. Giuliani, once the straight-arrow prosecutor who always played by the
rules, and Trump, the real estate huckster who never did, are more alike in key
ways than they at first seemed — and they respect most in each other what
others cringe at or even find criminal.
The origins of this
“bromance” can be traced back long before Trump arrived in Washington.
It has been 37 years
since Giuliani made his first of many public splashes. Millions of Americans
are too young to remember him back then, but Trump is not. His was a movie hero’s story (and movies were made
about it). History has cast a more skeptical eye on Giuliani’s actions, but at
the time he seemed as dynamic as any figure in American life. His victorious
crusade to put the Commission —
leaders of all five mafia families — behind bars was almost unimaginable in its
audacity. (Others felt the audacious part was how much credit he took for the
case.) His prosecution of Ivan Boesky, Michael Milken and
other Wall Street titans captivated the nation. He seemed fearless,
incorruptible, pure. “America’s greatest crime-fighter,”
President George H.W. Bush called Giuliani in 1989, comparing him to Teddy
Roosevelt, Thomas Dewey, Fiorello LaGuardia and Eliot Ness.
One idea has shaped Giuliani’s whole career: Everyone is
wrong but me
But he was also
hailed as a champion of his city, a brilliant prosecutor who was a hardscrabble
Brooklynite at heart, a member of a family that included both cops and mobsters. To Trump,
another outer-borough tough guy with Manhattan aspirations, he was a kindred
spirit.
Giuliani would move
on to an equally epic role as mayor of New York that may well have been a
template for Trump’s presidency. Succeeding the genteel David Dinkins, who left
office in 1993 with the streets in disarray and the government hemorrhaging
billions of dollars in deficits, Giuliani was Dinkins’s temperamental opposite,
virtually grabbing an unruly city by the throat and forcing it to cry uncle. He
was a municipal tyrant, lacerating his opponents as “jerks,” bullying school chancellors,
police commissioners and a long list of public officials and business leaders
into submission. He was a “human hand grenade,” an
editorial in the New York Times said in 1998, two decades before John Bolton
would use the same words to describe him during the Ukraine scandal. The Times
endorsed Giuliani for reelection in 1997, comparing his temperament to “nuclear
fission” and hailing him for turning the city around and reshaping its future. Four years later, on Sept. 11, 2001,
his leadership made him internationally celebrated.
Trump watched mostly
from a distance at the time, but the impression Giuliani made on him was
consequential. Decades later, he speaks about him with unusual deference,
venerating Giuliani’s leadership in New York at almost every opportunity (“by
far the greatest mayor in the history of NYC …” Trump’s tweet announcing
Giuliani’s coronavirus diagnosis began). Giuliani’s take-no-prisoners approach
as mayor made a profound impact on his fellow New Yorkers, and he may have been
a role model for Trump, who assumed the presidency with little knowledge of
government beyond what he read in the New York Post each day.
Giuliani’s mania for
success, fierce intelligence and unusual passion for risk led him to score the
kind of accomplishments that most elected officials can only dream about. But
he is a dark, often bizarre figure who subsists on conflict and melodrama, and
his personal and political decisions can range from baffling to stupendously
bad. By 2016, he had suffered grievously from such poor choices. He flamed out
as a presidential candidate in 2008 with a series of political miscalculations,
then inexplicably forfeited the Godlike stature he’d acquired after 9/11 with
snarling personal attacks on Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton, and rabid
performances at Republican conventions. Seduced by the financial rewards of his
fame, he made tens of millions advising a long list of dictators and other
shadowy figures. His behavior left him out of his party’s mainstream, so when
Trump came calling, Giuliani jumped.
Since then, he has
arguably done more damage to Trump’s presidency than anyone aside from the
president himself. He was the driving force behind the Ukraine scandal, which
led to Trump’s impeachment. His erratic television appearances during the
Mueller investigation sparked ridicule. It was Giuliani and former New Jersey
governor Chris Christie who prepped Trump before his disastrous first
presidential debate against Joe Biden. Giuliani’s risible efforts to prove
electoral fraud have gone nowhere in court or state legislatures, and have
earned him mockery for their amateurishness.
Yet Giuliani has
survived while a legion of other Trump advisers have long since been pushed
overboard. Aides say the president considers him a peer. He and Trump share
a bond that the president will not break, regardless of how much havoc his
lawyer causes him. The two men are conspiracy theorists, and wind one another
up over stories about missing servers, manipulated voting machines and secret
payoffs to Biden. Both see their adversaries as enemies. Both favor
scorched-earth tactics against critics. Giuliani is the smarter and more
strategic of the two; Trump has more common sense and better instincts.
But one is the boss
and the other is his employee, and so Giuliani has trudged on in his dismal
fight to overturn the election, fighting a losing battle for Trump at the
expense of his own legacy.
Giuliani was 39 when
he became a celebrated U.S. attorney. He is now 76, and his efforts to play the
hero prosecutor’s role one last time have evoked a poignant desperation. His
team’s lawsuits in Pennsylvania, Arizona and other states have been thrown out
by a multitude of incredulous judges (“stitched together like Frankenstein’s
monster,” wrote U.S. District Judge Matthew W. Brann of the team’s Pennsylvania
suit). Giuliani’s “witnesses” to election fraud have become Internet memes and
“SNL” fodder. His screw-ups and lies have made him a punching bag for
late-night hosts. “Jared Kushner wanted a ‘James Baker-like’ figure,” the New Yorker wrote in
November, “but he ended up with a ragtag bunch of lawyers led by a raving
Rudolph Giuliani.” That’s a common sentiment in Washington these days, and it
must sting. At another point in his career, Giuliani’s entrance into a case
like this would have been seen as James Baker-like.
But if Washington is
laughing at Giuliani, Trump doesn’t seem to be in on the joke. Perhaps he
respects him too much for his long-ago exploits. Or maybe it’s because Giuliani
is still telling his boss what he wants to hear: that President-elect Biden
stole the election from him, and that the battle to upend the results is still
winnable. The number of presidential lawyers willing to utter that delusion
publicly or privately has dwindled to a tiny handful led by Giuliani, and Trump
is an enthusiastic audience.
Giuliani certainly
has reason to stay on Trump’s good side. Having played his cards badly over the
years and now in the twilight of his epic career, he has watched his
preternatural need for relevance crash into his dwindling options. His business
fortunes, speaking fees, relevance to the media — even his potential escape
from prosecution — are at Trump’s mercy. It’s a precarious place to be, and a
humbling comedown.
The president’s
lawyer has reportedly requested a $20,000
per day fee for his work, but that isn’t the most lucrative reward Trump has to
offer. The same U.S. attorney’s office Giuliani once led is investigating his
morass of foreign dealings, trying to determine whether Giuliani and the
various shadowy foreign characters he has aligned himself with have broken
lobbying laws. Trump is dangling a preemptive pardon that would
end Giuliani’s nightmare before it begins (he denies he has requested one but
has not said whether he would accept it).
Potential indictments
aside, Giuliani’s power is slipping away as Inauguration Day nears. His
clients, foreign and otherwise, will have far less use for his services when
the White House doors slam shut. With his reputation tarnished by his public
behavior and his utility to his party degraded by his over-the-top defense of
Trump, his only path forward is with the Trump diaspora, where the base still
views Giuliani as the sheriff of Wall Street and the hero of 9/11. Regardless
of what the president does next, he will always need people to defend him.
The political world
now awaits Trump’s post-White House moves with curiosity and trepidation. With
few options open for a next act of his own, Giuliani won’t be far behind.
