Friday, April 21, 2023
Tuesday, April 18, 2023
NEW INC. MAGAZINE COLUMN BY HOWARD TULLMAN
Election Spending Has Become a
Waste of Money. Only Advertising is Worse.
Chicago's recent mayoral election demonstrates how broken the system is. Meanwhile, there's no market too small to dissuade Big Pharma from massively advertising its wares.
BY HOWARD TULLMAN, GENERAL MANAGING PARTNER, G2T3V AND CHICAGO HIGH TECH INVESTORS@TULLMAN
Indifferent and ignorant voters get the results and the leaders they deserve, goes an old political theory. And judging by the recent mayoral election results in Chicago, the city’s citizens certainly got the shaft. The untried and untested mayor-elect was ultimately chosen by less than 20% of the eligible voters. The majority of voters, around 65%, stayed home. They didn’t come, they didn’t care, and they couldn’t be bothered. It was a “meh” mandate for mediocrity, meaningless maxims, and misinformation. An inexperienced guy, Brandon Johnson, a teachers’ union lobbyist who hadn’t bothered to pay his own bills, fines and debts, and wanted to defund the police, is now in charge of a $28 billion budget. Sad but not shocking.
Even after four years of the utterly unqualified and incompetent Lori Lightfoot -- a mayor who’s left the desolate city in shock and despair with newly resumed warm weather wilding -- the voters failed again to select a competent and knowledgeable leader. Of course, Chicago’s not alone in that department. After 4 painful years and all the lessons of Trump’s lack of interest in or any qualifications to lead, it’s still clear that hyper-partisan politics are blinding large parts of the public to the true requirements of successful governance. Too many people look no further than someone’s alleged party affiliation at the polls to make their choices. We know now for sure is that consistently painting Paul Vallas, the losing candidate who was a lifelong registered Democratic, as a closet Republican in a supposedly non-partisan election was the kiss of death given today’s totally tribal political warfare. Nothing else really mattered, although the timely Trump indictment days before the vote was the icing on the partisan cake that made sure that Johnson would limp across the finish line. In Johnson’s case, having a field army of teacher’s union workers to wrangle 30,000 young voters to the polls on Election Day also didn’t hurt. One encouraging prospect is that— at least in Chicago— we won’t have to hear the MAGA morons chanting “Go Brandon” any time soon.
But what’s really shocking is the staggering amounts of money raised, spent, and largely wasted by the two runoff candidates on ugly and angry media, old-world marketing materials, pollsters and doorknockers, and political consultants of every size, shape and flavor. You would think that no one had explained to these guys and their “consultants” that traditional ad media strategies and the old analog channels were dead meat and that the only effective games in town were social media, word of mouth, and precise digital marketing. Millions were wasted with little or nothing to show for the effort or the expenditures. And, of course, thanks to the Supreme Court’s tortured view that money is speech, we only rarely know the sources of the largest chunks of the dollars flowing into these campaigns or the objectives of anonymous donors.
Waste is one of mankind’s worst inventions. Nature doesn’t abide waste. Everything has a use and a purpose, and the world has worked reasonably well (at least so far) because nothing in nature is ever done in vain. It’s only when stupid people insert themselves and their feckless, selfish acts and concerns into the mainstream that our climate, culture, and country are all increasingly imperiled. Nothing seems likely to interrupt this accelerating slide into oblivion because no one who’s getting paid wants to interrupt the flood of funding. And no one in charge or in office is willing to be the first to de-escalate the crazy spending. We can only expect more of same and worse from our political “leaders” even when actually winning an election (much like the dog who catches the car) these days seems like second or third prize and an invitation to years of pain, self-flagellation, and embarrassment. No wonder that anyone with a brain or a real job doesn’t want any of these positions.
In a city struggling with rampant crime, shuttered schools, harrowing levels of homelessness, hospitals constantly closing, and growing food insecurity for thousands of families, two politicians pissed away more than $30 million in a matter of months to ultimately elect a deceitful and chronically underemployed union organizer who was good at pretending to be up to the governance task without ever uttering a word of substance. The people would have been better served and the pols would have accomplished far more if they had just paid each of their few supporters a cash stipend to show up and vote in the old Chicago way. And, if you look at the current state of shooting and looting in Chicago, even before the new guy takes office, it’s clear that there’s unlikely to be much improvement in the unsettling situation any time soon.
We saw the same kind of lucre lunacy and ludicrous spending – around $42 million - right across the state border in another “non-partisan” race for the Wisconsin Supreme Court, which set national records for outlays in that type of contest. At least in that instance, the Democratic backers and funders from across the country got the kind of respectful turnout they were targeting and the MAGA sore loser, conservative Daniel Kelly, got precisely the major 10-point drubbing he deserved from liberal Janet Protasiewicz. Interestingly enough, the outcome analysis to date suggests that the historic win and the margin was largely driven by youth turnout which had little to do with ad spend and everything to do to already well-seated Roe vs Wade anxiety.
While current politics may be one of the most visible and obnoxious levels of excessive ad spending, the problem is far more serious and widespread. Every dollar that any business spends is precious; no one can afford to waste scarce resources on old-fashioned “spray and pray” campaigns or other brute force initiatives based more on faint hopes than hard facts. In the frenzy to get back to business, or to get their businesses back, or to get their story out in the midst of the overwhelming noise and clutter, millions of dollars that should be spent on R&D or productivity enhancements are being squandered on repetitive and useless marketing and ad campaigns which no one wants to see.
It seems like the unending glut of pharma ads – even running the identical ad several times in the same commercial break – is a conscious effort by these advertisers to drive viewers away from traditional broadcast TV. Right now, no industry is spending more on linear TV advertising than Big Pharma. In 2022, the top 10 pharma ad spenders combined for a total of $1.68 billion in TV ad spend. Who, apart from the miniscule numbers of actual sufferers of these exotic “diseases” and conditions, do they think is interested in messages where the list of risks, abuse, and frightening side effects is substantially longer and a more material part of the ad’s content than any benefit claims? Who’s responsible for the seemingly weekly creation of new two and three-letter diseases like TED that no one’s ever heard of, but which may be secretly plaguing them at this very moment? Who is concerned these days about confusing their penis with bent carrots and other supermarket vegetables?
The arcane references, technical language, descriptive behaviors, prohibitions against use with conflicting named drugs, and other cautions are completely unintelligible to 99% of the viewing population. I’m not sure, for example, that anyone even knows what TD or GmG are, and the doctors complain all the time now that patients come in asking for the “purple pill” even before they’ve been examined or diagnosed. You’d think that the FDA had already been defunded at this point – the regulators have completely abandoned any attempts to regulate these ads which nothing more than lists of symptoms to suck sufferers in and catalogues of side effects to cover the vendors’ bases and potential liability.
The other big and relatively new bucket (and check box) is the politically correct and DEI-infused ads that literally litter the latest pitches from almost every agency and brand imaginable. The most striking element of these new offerings and paeans to whatever’s woke this week is that although they’re running on broadcast channels, they couldn’t be more particularly and narrowly targeted to highly specific, ridiculously small, and typically already suffering populations. Do we really need to be bombarded nightly with suggestions that we “PrEP” this (whatever that means) or “Detect” that? You wouldn’t go wrong concluding that the purpose of creating and running these ads has little or nothing to do with actual sales and everything to do with satisfying corporate and political demands and desires to demonstrate virtue signaling.
The latest Bud Lite trans spokesperson debacle (and the bizarre non-apology, non-explanation letter from the Anheuser Busch CEO) is just another example of busting Bud and burning down the house in the alleged name of expanded representation. Of course, now that the Republican old guard has reminded the young and stupid turks in the party that AB is one of their largest donors, they’ve been told to back away from this particular stunt. Amazon’s ad featuring a teenage girl with a prominent mustache that is the absolute centerpiece of the ad is just another tweak waiting to happen. Does anyone believe that these ad campaigns on traditional broadcast TV make the slightest economic sense when the demographics of the actual viewing population continue to skew older and older every quarter?
One of the few smart things that Elon ever did was to spend almost nothing on Tesla advertising while GM, Chrysler, Ford, and Toyota typically spent almost $2 billion a year. At the same time, Tesla’s $3 billion spend on R&D was greater than the combined spends of Chrysler, GM and Ford. Guess who’s still leading the R&D race?
We’re back –
for far too many companies – to the Wanamaker times. In the 1920s, department
store entrepreneur John Wanamaker was the first guy who honestly acknowledged
that at least half of what he spent on advertising was wasted. But that he
didn’t know which half.
Sunday, April 16, 2023
The Anniversary
The Anniversary
Tuesday, April 11, 2023
NEW INC. MAGAZINE COLUMN BY HOWARD TULLMAN
You Can't Be Creative If You're Fearful
In the current political
environment, your team could be exercising too much caution. You need to free
them from their fears or risk falling into mediocrity.
BY HOWARD
TULLMAN, GENERAL MANAGING PARTNER, G2T3V AND CHICAGO HIGH TECH
INVESTORS@TULLMAN
One of the saddest
things about our current state of affairs is how much time and effort is
expended on imaginary and inane fears largely manufactured by manipulative
media, MAGA-poisoned pols, and the always dependable religious nuts and
conspiracy mongers. These ridiculous rants and performative stunts have long
passed the point of novelty or entertainment.
They've also become so
pervasive and problematic that smart leaders and managers can no longer
ignore them. Because when people are confused and lose confidence in their
leaders and institutions, they're too easily driven by their fears and not
their hopes. And in startups especially, it's all about hopes and dreams for
the world, not fears of and for it.
This increasingly dire
situation -- where so many team members in firms of all sizes are losing faith
-- would be plenty painful but not entirely devastating if these garbage
conversations, infantile behaviors, and trashings of the rule of law were
confined to D.C. Because having the Republicans continue to make fools of
themselves certainly isn't the worst thing that could emerge from a Congress
now led (loosely speaking) by fools, fascists, frauds, and football coaches.
It's actually something of a relief that this crew couldn't pass a serious bill
that had any prospect of becoming law. Nor could they fashion a budget that
made even the slightest economic sense if their lives - instead of their
notoriety, incomes, and fundraising -- depended on it.
But when the non-stop
noise begins to impact our own employees' attitudes and our businesses'
prospects, it's another matter entirely. When you walk around and see more of
your people worrying than working, arguing about nonsense instead of advancing
the company, and focusing on a foreboding future, it's time for you to step in
-- like it or not -- because there's nothing more frightening than scared
people.
As Warren Zevon
sang: "you're a whole different
person when you're scared." Your people don't move, they
don't think, they're unable to act, and your business soon stands still. Fear,
whether warranted or unreasonable, is a great paralyzer. Fear can suck the
momentum out of any movement, and it's the leader's job to break through the
clutter, redirect the conversations, and make it clear that (a) worrying and
fueling their fears is a waste of energy and imagination and (b) other people's
fears and fantasies don't have to become theirs unless they let them. Their
faith in you, themselves, their abilities, and the vision needs to be stronger
than their fear. Worrying is like sitting in a rocking chair: you're in motion,
but you don't get anywhere.
Too many talents now
believe that every step forward, every innovation, and every act of change may
be perilous and needs to be checked, conformed, and revised to anticipate a
whole host of imagined fears. This hesitation can hobble the best instincts and
the most creative ideas of even the strongest and most talented players in
business and throughout our society.
The end result of this
self-censorship is that the ideas, products, and other creations are less than
they can and should be. Seeking constant consensus and avoiding the sharp edges
of creative ideas is a certain formula for mediocrity. Fear can
chase the best dreams into hiding. Worrying incessantly about the future is
like praying for what you don't want. It doesn't save you or take away
tomorrow's troubles, but it can simply kill today's best prospects. It never
pays to rehearse for bad news.
In the newest staging of
the classic Lerner and Loewe musical Camelot, which opened more than 60 years
ago, the New York Times reports that Aaron Sorkin
of West Wing fame felt the pressure to reimagine and
contextualize two of the musical's songs in order to pre-empt the umbrage
and outrage he expected from the woke and intently revisionist
crowd. If there's anyone who should be more than comfortable in his own
judgment and confident in his craft, it would be this guy. Yet even he found
himself in doubt, and for no good reason.
The first song, How to Handle a
Woman, was an obvious feminist landmine. Apart from the sheer
stupidity of anyone objecting to a song of roughly a dozen lines wherein
the sole gender management advice is to "simply love the
woman," it's hard to imagine how even an auteur as talented as Sorkin
could improve on that simple and succinct message to placate the play's easily
offended social critics. But we shall soon see how he threads that nebulous
needle.
The second song's
deficiencies are less clear. Apparently asking What Do the
Simple Folks Do? is insufferably classicist. I'm not sure
whether the theoretically offended group whose interests the zealots would
surely be protecting are actual "simple" people, whatever that may
mean these days, or whether the intended allusion and apparent slur was assumed
to be directed to the proletariat in general. Whatever the theoretical slander,
it was clear to Sorkin that changing the lyrics of this 63-year-old classic was
essential. In the event that you're curious, what the simple folks did according
to the original score "to shed their weary lot" and to "brighten
up their day" was to whistle and sing. And dance. Much the same advice
that the Seven Dwarfs shared with Snow White. Maybe DeSantis needs to get on
Disney again to clean up this mess.
The implicit
anti-classist suggestion of the know-it-alls is that we're not supposed to
speculate about what others do or think to address their concerns and angst.
Nor can we comment in any respect on their behaviors because such commentary
would clearly offend or trigger them and certainly hurt their feelings. This
whole ado only applies, apparently, to the allegedly privileged actions and
inconsiderate efforts of Broadway writers, revisers, and producers who are
restaging high-end historic musicals.
But only some musical
expressions are subject to liberal oversight and outrage. Rappers are free to
slime and slander women and cops and employ anti-Semitic tropes in their
"art" without anyone objecting. MAGA morons led by the Orange Monster
can corrupt and bastardize the sacred words of the Pledge of Allegiance without
complaint or commentary from the same egg-shell elites and their servile media.
The connection between
Broadway musicals and businesses is that you can't have your people getting so
concerned about future criticism - internal or external, smart or stupid,
talks or tweets - that they become tentative and self-editing in ways that sap
the momentum of your business. In the music game, when a hit group starts
working on their second album, too often it's all about fear, not instinct, and
creativity just doesn't happen. You have to be prepared and willing to bet on
an uncertain future and put your heart and soul into the effort and let the
chips fall where they may.
Most businesses are more
likely to lose out due to their inhibitions and reluctance to step on toes,
move aggressively against the competition, and take reasonable risks than from
their inability to perform or their other vulnerabilities. As the boss, you
need to help the team focus on finding something to hold on to that is more
important than their fears. Whoever can see and manage through fear will be the
ultimate winner. The caterpillar is safe in the cocoon, but it's the butterfly
that is beautiful.
Thursday, April 06, 2023
LINKS TO RELATED SITES
- My Personal Website
- HAT Speaker Website
- My INC. Blog Posts
- My THREADS profile
- My Wikipedia Page
- My LinkedIn Page
- My Facebook Page
- My X/Twitter Page
- My Instagram Page
- My ABOUT.ME page
- G2T3V, LLC Site
- G2T3V page on LinkedIn
- G2T3V, LLC Facebook Page
- My Channel on YOUTUBE
- My Videos on VIMEO
- My Boards on Pinterest
- My Site on Mastodon
- My Site on Substack
- My Site on Post
LINKS TO RELATED BUSINESSES
- 1871 - Where Digital Startups Get Their Start
- AskWhai
- Baloonr
- BCV Social
- ConceptDrop (Now Nexus AI)
- Cubii
- Dumbstruck
- Gather Voices
- Genivity
- Georama (now QualSights)
- GetSet
- HighTower Advisors
- Holberg Financial
- Indiegogo
- Keeeb
- Kitchfix
- KnowledgeHound
- Landscape Hub
- Lisa App
- Magic Cube
- MagicTags/THYNG
- Mile Auto
- Packback Books
- Peanut Butter
- Philo Broadcasting
- Popular Pays
- Selfie
- SnapSheet
- SomruS
- SPOTHERO
- SquareOffs
- Tempesta Media
- THYNG
- Tock
- Upshow
- Vehcon
- Xaptum





