Dear Justice Roberts,
It has come to my attention through
your various media appearances that your feelings are hurt — that people view
you and your Court as political actors, which you insist is not an accurate
understanding of what the Court does.
So let me resolve the confusion: the
misunderstanding is yours, not ours. People believe your Court is political
because it is and acts so in plain view of the nation.
You unleash unlimited corporate money
into elections by inventing constitutional protections for concentrated wealth.
You dismantle voting protections while
dining with the very political movement that benefits from their
destruction.
You expand presidential immunity in
ways conveniently favorable to a corrupt executive you have rewarded with
extraordinary deference, 90% deference.
And then you perform public
astonishment when Americans recognize your pattern. Your Court did not merely
'interpret' the Constitution. It selectively hollowed it out whenever
democratic participation threatened entrenched power.
Citizens United accelerated
America’s transformation into an oligarchy where billionaires and corporations
wield more political influence than millions of citizens combined.
Shelby County gutted the Voting Rights
Act, after which states moved with remarkable speed to burden the very voters
the Act was designed to protect.
The immunity ruling signaled that
sufficient power can place a president beyond meaningful accountability.
Then you publicly mourn the collapse
of trust. What exactly did you think would happen?
Legitimacy is not something a court
grants itself while issuing ideologically convenient outcomes wrapped in
constitutional language — when the public is fortunate enough to even receive a
full opinion instead of another consequential ruling buried in the shadow
docket.
Legitimacy is earned through
restraint, consistency, ethical seriousness, and fidelity to principle even
when principle is inconvenient to power. This is precisely the credibility
your Court squandered.
We understand perfectly well what we
have been watching. We all see you and your court and its role in what our
nation has become. And we are furious — not because we are too ignorant to
understand constitutional law, but because we are capable of reading the
Constitution you claim to defend- while watching this Court repeatedly twist it
to serve its own ideological will.
History will remember this era. And
it will remember you and your Court- not as a guardian of constitutional
democracy, but as a key institution that eroded it. That is already your legacy, so stop whining- you earned a
nation's scorn.


